Substack vs Medium: Which Publishing Platform Pays Writers More?
Substack vs Medium compared: revenue share, payouts, audience reach, and which publishing platform actually pays writers more in 2026.
Key Takeaways
- Substack writers keep roughly 90% of subscription revenue and own their email list.
- Medium pays passively via its Partner Program based on member read time, not subscriptions.
- Medium gives instant built-in audience; Substack requires you to drive growth yourself.
- Substack earnings are transparent per-subscriber; Medium payouts are pooled and opaque.
- Choose Substack for ownership and direct monetization, Medium for reach and passivity.
Quick Answer
Substack pays writers more directly because you keep roughly 90% of subscription revenue after Stripe fees and own the paying-reader relationship, while Medium pays indirectly through its Partner Program based on member read time. Choose Substack if you want to build a paid newsletter and own your subscriber list; choose Medium if you want immediate discovery from a large built-in audience without selling anything. The core trade-off is ownership-plus-effort versus reach-plus-passivity: Substack hands you the audience and the payment rails but you must drive growth yourself, whereas Medium surfaces your posts to existing readers but caps and controls your earnings.
Substack vs Medium: Overview
Writers building a paid newsletter and owning their audience
Free to publish; Substack takes 10% of paid subscription revenue (plus Stripe fees)
No platform fee for free newsletters; 10% cut on paid subs + ~2.9% + $0.30 Stripe per transaction
Writers who want instant reach and passive earnings without selling subscriptions
Free to publish; earn via Partner Program based on member read time
Free to write; readers pay Medium $5/mo or $50/yr; writers earn a share of that pool
Substack vs Medium: Feature Comparison
| Feature | Substack | Medium |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue model | Direct paid subscriptions, ~90% keptWinner | Read-time payout pool from member fees |
| Audience ownership | Full — exportable email listWinner | None — Medium owns the relationship |
| Built-in discovery | Recommendations + Notes | Large algorithmic audienceWinner |
| Setup effort | Low, but you must grow the list | Near zeroWinner |
| Earnings transparency | High — you see every subscriberWinner | Low — pooled and opaque |
| Long-term control | High — portable audienceWinner | Low — platform-dependent |
Pros & Cons
Substack
Pros
- Writers keep ~90% of subscription revenue after the platform cut
- You own your email subscriber list and can export it anytime
- Native paid-subscription, recommendations, and Notes-driven discovery
- No ads or paywall confusion — readers pay you directly
- Free podcast, video, and chat features bundled in
Cons
- No built-in discovery audience the way Medium has — you drive growth
- 10% revenue cut is high once you scale to large subscriber counts
- Limited design and CMS customization versus self-hosted options
- You handle churn, marketing, and retention entirely yourself
Medium
Pros
- Large built-in audience and algorithmic distribution from day one
- Zero setup — publish and potentially get read immediately
- Partner Program pays passively without you selling anything
- Clean reading experience and strong SEO on established domain
- Boost and curation can dramatically amplify a single post
Cons
- You do not own readers or emails — Medium controls the relationship
- Earnings are opaque, pooled, and often low per article
- Metered paywall can limit who sees your work
- Algorithm changes can erase distribution overnight
Our Verdict: Substack vs Medium
Substack and Medium pay writers in fundamentally different ways. Substack pays more to writers who can convert readers into paying subscribers, since you keep close to 90% of revenue and own a portable email list. Medium pays more passively but typically less per piece, rewarding volume and discovery rather than direct monetization. Most serious writers eventually find the owned-audience model more durable. Use Substack if you want to build and monetize a loyal paid audience you control; use Medium if you want immediate reach and passive read-time income without the work of selling subscriptions.
Substack vs Medium — FAQs
Does Substack or Medium pay writers more?
It depends on your model. Substack typically pays more to writers who can sell paid subscriptions, because you keep about 90% of revenue after the platform cut and Stripe fees. Medium pays passively through its Partner Program based on member read time, which usually amounts to less per article but requires no selling. High-effort writers with a niche audience earn far more on Substack; casual writers chasing reach may earn small passive income on Medium.
How does the Substack revenue cut work?
Substack is free for free newsletters and only charges when you turn on paid subscriptions. It takes a 10% cut of paid subscription revenue, and Stripe takes roughly 2.9% plus $0.30 per transaction on top. So on a $10/month subscriber you keep around $8.40 after both fees. There is no upfront cost, and free publications pay nothing.
Can I move my audience from Medium to Substack?
Not easily. Medium does not give you direct email access to your readers, so there is no clean export of a subscriber list. You can encourage Medium readers to subscribe to a separate email list, but you are rebuilding the relationship. Substack, by contrast, lets you export your full subscriber list at any time, which is the main ownership advantage of the platform.
Which platform is better for discovery and new readers?
Medium is stronger for cold discovery because it has a large built-in audience and an algorithm that surfaces your posts to existing members. Substack relies on recommendations between newsletters and its Notes feed, which helps but does not match Medium reach. If your priority is being found by new readers fast, Medium has the edge; if your priority is converting and keeping readers, Substack wins.
Should a beginner writer start on Substack or Medium?
Beginners who want to test whether anyone reads their work, with zero setup and possible passive income, often start on Medium. Beginners who already have a small following or want to build an owned audience from day one are better served by Substack, since the email list is portable and monetization is built in. Many writers start on Medium for reach and migrate to Substack once they want to monetize.
Try the Best AI Platform — Free
Assisters brings the best of AI together in one platform. No credit card required to start.